TOMS RIVER, NJ – The Bais Brucha congregation in Toms River celebrated a significant legal victory, concluding a three-year battle with the township. A federal judge found that Toms River engaged in discriminatory practices against the Orthodox Jewish community, obstructing the shul’s expansion efforts.
This landmark decision paves the way for Bais Brucha to construct a 4,680-square-foot synagogue in the North Dover section, catering to its increasing membership. Attorney Roman P. Storzer, representing Bais Brucha, emphasized the ruling as an affirmation of religious freedom and equality under the law.
The dispute began when Toms River denied Bais Brucha’s zoning permit, citing regulations that prohibited houses of worship in the desired location. However, the lawsuit highlighted inconsistencies in applying these zoning laws, pointing out allowances for nonreligious assemblies in similar zones. The court’s ruling underscored the township’s failure to demonstrate a compelling reason for these restrictions, which substantially burdened religious exercise.
Allegations of anti-Semitic motivations behind the 2009 zoning laws were bolstered by campaign materials from a township council race, insinuating opposition to Orthodox Jewish development. The court’s decision marks a critical step toward eliminating barriers to religious practice and affirms the congregation’s right to expand its facilities in Toms River.
The property litigated is located at 1181 Hickory Street in North Dover.