MIDDLETOWN, NJ – Middletown isn’t exactly the pizza capital of America, or even New Jersey, but that doesn’t mean you can’t find a great slice in New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy’s hometown.
Middletown is home to some seriously good pizza, and local Yelpers have made their voices heard. Whether you’re looking for a coal-fired classic, a trendy pie, or a nostalgic neighborhood favorite, these top-rated pizzerias serve up the best slices in town.
Panko Pizza: A Bold and Trendy Choice
With a modern atmosphere and a reputation for excellence, Panko Pizza is a standout in Middletown. Some reviewers even call it the best pizza in Monmouth County, a bold claim backed by high praise from loyal customers. The trendy and slightly romantic setting makes it perfect for a casual date night or a gathering with friends who appreciate high-quality ingredients and authentic flavors.
Zoni’s Coal Fired Pizza: A Cozy BYOB Spot
Zoni’s Coal Fired Pizza has built a loyal fanbase with its crispy, flavorful crusts and deliciously charred edges, thanks to its signature coal-fired ovens.
A favorite among locals, this spot is known for its relaxed, casual vibe and welcoming BYOB policy—perfect for pairing your favorite bottle of wine with a hot, fresh pizza. Beyond pizza, their fresh salads and Italian-inspired dishes make it a versatile choice for any occasion.
Romeo’s Pizza & Restaurant: A Longtime Favorite
For those who grew up in the Middletown area, Romeo’s Pizza & Restaurant is a household name. With years of experience crafting delicious, high-quality pizza, Romeo’s remains a go-to spot for locals looking for a satisfying slice.
Whether you’re craving a classic pie or something more elaborate, this casual yet classy establishment never disappoints.
Pasquale’s Pizzeria III: Friendly Service and Great Pizza
Pasquale’s Pizzeria III is known for more than just its pizza—it’s also a place where service matters. Reviewers often mention the friendly, welcoming atmosphere that keeps them coming back. Their menu features Italian-inspired options, including fresh salads, making it a great spot for those looking for variety alongside their pizza.
Rosie’s Pizza: The Newcomer Making an Impression
Despite being open for just six weeks, Rosie’s Pizza has already caught the attention of pizza lovers in Middletown.
While still new, the buzz around their pizza suggests they could soon become a local favorite. With strong early reviews and a reputation for high-quality ingredients, it’s worth keeping an eye on this rising star in the town’s pizza scene.
From trendy spots to old-school favorites, Middletown’s pizza scene has something for every taste. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of coal-fired crusts or prefer a classic New Jersey-style slice, these Yelper-approved pizzerias are serving up some of the best pizza in town.