Papa’s Tomato Pies in Robbinsville, NJ, is a historic gem, serving up Trenton-style tomato pies since 1912. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s an institution. The tomato pies here are known for their perfectly crispy, thin crusts and a tangy, flavorful tomato sauce that’s applied with just the right amount of restraint.
The Mustard Pie is a standout—yes, mustard. It sounds unconventional, but the light layer of spicy brown mustard under the sauce and cheese offers a surprising twist that regulars rave about. Even if you’re not typically a mustard fan, it’s worth trying for a unique flavor experience.
Another fan favorite is the classic sausage pie, where the toppings are generous, and the crust stays crispy throughout. Some locals swear by the sausage and garlic combo, adding that extra punch to the already robust flavors. Despite the pie’s simplicity, each bite feels like a perfected balance between crunchy crust and savory toppings.
That said, not every experience is flawless. There have been a few grumbles from customers about undercooked pizzas and the occasional mishap with slicing. But the overwhelming majority still come back for the nostalgia, the charm, and of course, the pies.
If you’re a pizza purist or a fan of crispy, thin-crust pizza, Papa’s is worth a detour. And if you’re ever feeling adventurous, don’t skip the mustard pie—it might just change your pizza game forever.