Pizza lovers in Newark, NJ, are in for a treat. The city and its surrounding areas are home to some standout pizzerias that deliver everything from traditional pies to wood-fired delights. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or prefer something a little more adventurous, here are some must-visit spots that are creating pizza magic in the Brick City.
Blaze Pizza on Broad Street is one of the top options for fast-fired, customizable pies. With their innovative “build your own pizza” model, Blaze gives you total control over what goes on your pizza, and the results are cooked up in minutes in a blazing-hot oven. Known for fresh ingredients and quick service, it’s the perfect place for anyone craving a crispy, personal pizza experience that doesn’t skimp on quality. Their thin-crust pizzas are a fan favorite, and their unlimited toppings option lets you go as simple or creative as you like.
For a cozier, more classic vibe, Ellie’s Bistro on Green Street is another hidden gem. This spot combines a relaxed atmosphere with seriously delicious pizza. The standout feature here is their flavorful crust, which perfectly balances softness and crispiness. The sauce is rich and savory, creating a pizza that feels both nostalgic and gourmet. It’s a go-to spot for people catching a game at the Prudential Center or just looking for a great slice downtown.
Another contender for best pizza in Newark is Queen Pizza II, located on Commerce Street. This family-run pizzeria offers a perfect example of why New Jersey pizza gets so much love. Known for its consistent quality and no-nonsense approach to pizza-making, Queen Pizza II has won over locals with its crispy thin crust and simple, flavorful toppings. Their friendly service and cozy atmosphere make this a beloved spot for regulars and visitors alike.
If you’re willing to venture a bit outside the city, Artie’s Pizza in nearby Maplewood is a must-visit. Their dough is legendary, and they don’t shy away from bold, creative toppings. The result is a pizza that feels both familiar and extraordinary, leaving a lasting impression long after the last slice. This pizzeria offers a more artisan take on pizza, and it’s a favorite among those looking for something beyond the usual pizza fare.
No Newark pizza tour is complete without mentioning Dickie Dee’s, an institution that’s been serving locals since 1958. While known primarily for their Italian hot dogs, their pizza is a hidden gem. Dickie Dee’s focuses on classic, thin-crust pizzas with that perfect balance of chewiness and crunch. If you love traditional pizza, this spot is a must-visit, and their meat-lover’s pie is a carnivore’s dream.
In a city like Newark, the pizza scene is as rich and diverse as its history, offering something for every kind of pizza lover. Whether you’re in the mood for quick, customizable pies or handcrafted artisanal creations, Newark has got you covered. So grab a slice—or a whole pie—and enjoy the deliciousness!