Do you love Sabrett’s dirty water dogs, or are you more of the Nathan’s hot dog on a grill type? Better yet, are you a yellow, deli, or brown mustard person?
Ketchup users need not apply as this article is only for normal people.
As summer unfolds across New Jersey, hot dog enthusiasts converge on boardwalks, backyard barbecues, and picnics, eager to enjoy this quintessential American treat. Alongside the variety of hot dogs, from Nathan’s to Thuman’s, the choice of mustard plays a pivotal role in enhancing the flavors of a perfectly grilled dog. Among the popular options like Nathan’s, Sabrett, French’s Yellow, and Gulden’s Spicy Brown, it’s Gulden’s Spicy Brown that stands out as the favorite mustard to top a New Jersey hot dog during the summer heat.

Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard, known for its robust flavor, complements the smoky sweetness of a grilled hot dog, making it a top choice for many New Jerseyans. Its spicy kick elevates the taste without overpowering the natural flavors of the meat, creating a perfect balance that has locals and visitors alike reaching for it at concession stands and grocery stores.
While mustard preferences can be as diverse as the hot dog brands themselves, the types of hot dogs preferred in New Jersey also vary widely, making the state a hotbed of hot dog diversity. Popular brands like Nathan’s and Sabrett lead the pack, particularly on the bustling boardwalks and during festive Fourth of July celebrations. Nathan’s, known for its snappy bite and robust flavor, is often the star at many gatherings, while Sabrett’s slightly garlicky undertone and tender texture make it a close favorite.

Other brands like Hebrew National appeal to those looking for a kosher option, with its distinct spiced flavor profile. Ballpark franks are favored for their juicy, beefy taste, ideal for a family cookout. Oscar Meyer offers a milder option that’s particularly popular among children, and Thuman’s, a local favorite, is renowned for its unique blend of spices and leaner meat composition.
The Fourth of July sees a surge in hot dog consumption, with these brands frequently featured at celebrations across the state. The traditional setting of a summer barbeque with grilled hot dogs, an assortment of mustards, and an array of toppings, is a scene repeated in countless New Jersey backyards. Whether it’s a Nathan’s or a Thuman’s, each hot dog finds its match in a mustard that brings out its best qualities.
As the summer continues, New Jersey’s love affair with hot dogs and mustard remains a staple of culinary tradition, demonstrating that simple ingredients can create the most memorable flavors. The next time you find yourself at a New Jersey boardwalk or backyard gathering, consider trying Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard on your hot dog and discover why it’s the favored choice among locals.
