Toms River, NJ, boasts a diverse and vibrant food scene, offering everything from indulgent Italian classics to creative sushi rolls and award-winning breakfast plates. Whether you’re in the mood for upscale dining or a cozy neighborhood spot, this town has something to satisfy every craving. Based on popular sentiment, customer reviews, and local buzz, here are some standout restaurants making waves in March 2025.
This list was compiled using a composite average of scores between Yelp, Trip Advisor, Google Reviews, and other restaurant ratings.
Xina Restaurant: Asian Fusion Excellence
Located on Hooper Avenue, Xina Restaurant is a local gem when it comes to Asian fusion. Regulars rave about the freshness of the sushi, particularly creative rolls like the Acapulco Roll, which features lobster tempura and white tuna for a luxurious bite. Beyond sushi, their Chinese-inspired dishes also shine, offering a well-rounded dining experience that seamlessly blends flavors. The ambiance is both stylish and inviting, making it a go-to spot for date nights and special occasions.
Shut Up and Eat: Breakfast with a Side of Whimsy
For a morning meal with personality, Shut Up and Eat is the place to be. This quirky diner on Hooper Avenue is known for its pajama-clad staff and playful atmosphere, making breakfast a fun, memorable experience. Diners love the customizable French Toast options and the hearty Midwestern sandwich packed with roast beef, provolone, and bacon. It’s not just about the food—it’s about the experience, and this beloved eatery delivers on both.
JBJ Soul Kitchen: Dining with a Purpose
Toms River is home to one of the locations of JBJ Soul Kitchen, a nonprofit restaurant backed by the Jon Bon Jovi Soul Foundation. More than just a meal, this eatery offers a pay-what-you-can model, ensuring everyone in the community has access to a quality dining experience. The menu focuses on comforting American cuisine, with three-course meals that feature fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The warm hospitality and mission-driven approach make it a must-visit for those looking to support a great cause while enjoying delicious food.
Tardi’s Ristorante Italiano: A Slice of Italy Since 1979
If classic Italian fare is calling your name, Tardi’s Ristorante Italiano is a top choice. A Toms River institution since 1979, this restaurant on Fischer Boulevard has earned a loyal following with dishes like Fusilli Alla Davina, featuring homemade pasta, shrimp, and prosciutto in a creamy sauce. The intimate, cozy setting makes it feel like a home away from home, where every dish is prepared with love and tradition.
Rue 561 Bistro: Upscale Yet Approachable
For those seeking a refined yet relaxed dining experience, Rue 561 Bistro on NJ-37 is a local favorite. Specializing in modern American cuisine, the menu features standout dishes like shrimp protein bowls and indulgent desserts such as the salted caramel pizzuki. The bistro balances sophistication with a welcoming atmosphere, making it perfect for both casual dinners and celebratory occasions.
B2 Bistro + Bar: A Vibrant Culinary Destination
Another strong player in the Toms River dining scene is B2 Bistro + Bar, offering a dynamic menu of contemporary American dishes, craft cocktails, and an energetic ambiance. Whether you’re craving expertly prepared seafood, juicy steaks, or inventive small plates, this spot has something for everyone. With its stylish décor and buzzing crowd, B2 Bistro is a hotspot for food lovers looking to enjoy a lively evening out.
Breakin Bread Eatery: Comfort Food with Heart
Since opening in 2020, Breakin Bread Eatery has carved out a reputation for its comforting Italian-American dishes. Customers keep coming back for its Pasta Fagioli and other hearty, home-style meals. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere make this newer addition to Toms River’s food scene a standout.
PaciDough’s Pizza Joint: The Talk of the Town
If there’s one pizza place currently dominating local food conversations, it’s PaciDough’s Pizza Joint. Recently crowned “Best in New Jersey” by Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports, this spot has become a must-visit for pizza lovers. Located on Hooper Avenue, it’s generating significant buzz with its perfectly crisp crust, high-quality toppings, and well-balanced flavors. If you’re a fan of a great slice, this should be at the top of your list.
Toms River continues to impress with its diverse array of restaurants, offering everything from elevated dining experiences to casual comfort food. Whether you’re in the mood for expertly crafted sushi, a nostalgic Italian dinner, or a feel-good breakfast, there’s no shortage of places to explore.